Polish Music Poll on Italian Forum

Najciekawsze - najsilniejszych.

Moderatorzy: gharvelt, Bartosz, Dobromir, Moderatorzy

Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 395
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Polish Music Poll on Italian Forum

Post autor: Taribo West »

On an italian forum i organized a music battle for non-english speaking countries.
The rules are simple, each user choose 4 songs from different artist for that country and other user vote that songs from 1 to 5
You cannot choose song in english and there can't be two songs from the same album.
At the end we have a chart of songs and a chart of user. The user that win in a country decide the next country to be played
Here you have the link to the result of each country we did till now


http://forum.ondarock.it/index.php?/top ... ?p=2555953
(now we are making countries from southern africa)

When i won (in Indonesia) i choose Poland and i think it can be curios for you to see the final result

1 Voo Voo Gdybym 2014 4,842
2 Klaus Mitffoch Strzeż się tych miejsc 1984 4,700
3 Lady Pank Kryzysowa narzeczona 1983 4,647
4 String Connection Bokra 1982 4,632
5 Tadeusz Woźniak Odcień ciszy 1974 4,619
6 Zbygniew Wodecki Rzuć to wszystko co złe 1976 4,619
6 Republika Śmierć w bikini 1983 4,619
8 Kult Polska 1987 4,600
9 Rezerwat Zaopiekuj się mną 1985 4,591
10 Ewa Bem Wyszłam za mąż, zaraz wracam 1976 4,571
10 Israel Wolny Naród 1986 4,571
12 Maanam Żądza pieniądza [versione singolo] 1980 4,571
13 SBB Memento z banalnym tryptykiem 1981 4,556
14 Marek Grechuta/Anawa Korowood 1971 4,524
15 Czesław Niemen Ach, jakie oczy 1969 4,500
15 Ziyo Idziemy Wytrwale 1989 4,500
17 andrzej zaucha Byłaś serca biciem 1988 4,476
18 Jacek Kaczmarski Epitafium dla Włodzimierza Wysockiego 1981 4,471
19 Obywatel GC Tak Tak to Ja 1988 4,450
19 Fogg Ostatnia niedziela 1936 4,450
21 Skaldowie Juhas zmarł 1972 4,429
21 Marek Biliński Kosmiczne opowiadania 1985 4,429
23 Lao Che Bajka o Misiu (tom pierwszy) 2015 4,428
24 Perfect Ale w koło jest wesoło 1981 4,400
25 de mono Kochać inaczej 1989 4,380
26 Armia Opowieść zimowa 1991 4,357
27 Ewa Demarczyk Grande Valse Brillante 1967 4,353
28 Aya Rl Nie zostawie 1985 4,350
28 Tomek Makowiecki+C206 Dziecko Księżyca 2013 4,350
28 Chłopcy z Placu Broni Kocham wolnosc 1990 4,350
31 Breakout Pomaluj moje sny 1971 4,333
32 Podsiadlo Najinowszy Klip 2018 4,333
33 Oddział Zamknięty Pokusy 1984 4,286
34 Fisz Emade Tworzywo Ślady 2014 4,250
35 Czesław Niemen Cztery ściany świata 1974 4,250
36 Martyna Jakubowicz W domach z betonu 1984 4,238
37 Myslovitz My 1999 4,238
38 Daab Ogrodu serce 1986 4,230
39 Tilt Mówię ci, że 1986 4,227
40 Zbigniew Namyslowski Winobranie 1973 4,222
41 KSU Moje bieszczady 1993 4,211
42 Czerwone Gitary Płoną góry płoną lasy 1971 4,150
43 Dawid podsiadlo Trójkąty i kwadraty 2013 4,125
43 L. Stadt Halo 2017 4,125
45 Strachy na lachy Ten Wiatrak Ta Lalka 2010 4,100
45 Organek Wiosna 2016 4,100
45 Basia Stępniak-Wilk & Grzegorz Turnau Bombonierka 2006 4,100
48 Mata Patointeligencja 2019 4,071
49 Turbo Dorosłe dzieci 1982 4,053
50 Roze Europy Podróże z Europy do Europy 1988 4,045
51 Budka Suflera Cień wielkiej góry 1975 4,000
51 Kortez Pierwsza 2017 4,000
51 Manaam Lucciola 1984 4,000
51 Happysad Smutnje ludzie 2014 4,000
51 sztywny pal azji Spotkanie z… 1988 4,000
56 Maria Peszek Modern Holocaust 2016 3,952
57 t. love Gnijący świat 2006 3,857
57 Krzysztof Komeda Lullaby 1968 3,857
59 PRO8L3M Stówa 2014 3,765
60 Dezerter Kto? 1987 3,700
61 Reni Jusis Jakby przez sen 2001 3,650
62 Batushka Yekteniya I 2015 3,333
63 Pablopavo i Ludziki Eleganccy Pesymiści 2014 3,250
64 Grammatik Puste pokoje (bębny grają miks) 2000 3,150
65 Wojciech Kilar Opening Titles 1999 3,142
66 Filth of Mankind Obledna Rzeczywistosc 2000 3,095
67 Jacaszek Rytm to nieśmiertelność II 2008 2,541


(the songs are 67, because we made some special where we are free to choose songs from the previous one, so i add in the chart all the polish songs we played till now)
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 395
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Post autor: Taribo West »

just some comment, Polish was one of the country was most appreciated, it has a really good average

My quartet was
SBB Memento z banalnym tryptykiem
Budka Suflera Cień wielkiej góry
Breakout Pomaluj moje sny
Zbigniew Namyslowski Winobranie

(i choose for last and i choose some artist that wasn't choosed by anyone)
Awatar użytkownika
Okechukwu
limitowana edycja z bonusową płytą
Posty: 4326
Rejestracja: 07.06.2007, 10:49

Post autor: Okechukwu »

So one can say, that on Italian forum you are ultra-conservative! :D A typical "dinosaur" I would say! :D
Awatar użytkownika
Bednaar
zremasterowany digipack z bonusami
Posty: 6741
Rejestracja: 11.04.2007, 08:36
Lokalizacja: Łódź

Post autor: Bednaar »

Voo Voo won the first place - my favourite Polish rock band :)
And my strong respect, that you have chosen Winobranie - actually, this is my favourite Polish jazz album ever :)
vertical_invader
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 395
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Post autor: Taribo West »

Bednaar pisze:Voo Voo won the first place - my favourite Polish rock band :)
And my strong respect, that you have chosen Winobranie - actually, this is my favourite Polish jazz album ever :)
Voo Voo song is also the best song ever till now in the context, no other song had a better average in any country

I think Winobranie is also one of my favourite one... maybe just after Astigmatic (i know i am not too original)
Awatar użytkownika
Okechukwu
limitowana edycja z bonusową płytą
Posty: 4326
Rejestracja: 07.06.2007, 10:49

Post autor: Okechukwu »

High place of Kaczmarski is really impressive. One could think, that without getting the lyrics and cultural context of the song, its impossible to like it more than for ex. Komeda Lullaby. Seems, that the song gives something extra special, something impossible do define.
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 395
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Post autor: Taribo West »

Okechukwu pisze:High place of Kaczmarski is really impressive. One could think, that without getting the lyrics and cultural context of the song, its impossible to like it more than for ex. Komeda Lullaby. Seems, that the song gives something extra special, something impossible do define.
Kaczmarski song i think it has really a strong energy and impetus and i think it is quite overwhelming. Lullaby was "punished" because too famous and not surprising (i think some user are quite snob)
Anyway you have to think that they just listen the song once or twice, so the impact of the song is important and Kaczmarski has a strong impact
Awatar użytkownika
Okechukwu
limitowana edycja z bonusową płytą
Posty: 4326
Rejestracja: 07.06.2007, 10:49

Post autor: Okechukwu »

I wonder, if di Andre had any chances here in Italian competition. I'm afraid he would get only my vote (even if his arrangements are deinitely richer than Kaczmarski - more attractive for "proggy" ear).
Ostatnio zmieniony 14.10.2021, 11:43 przez Okechukwu, łącznie zmieniany 1 raz.
Awatar użytkownika
Bednaar
zremasterowany digipack z bonusami
Posty: 6741
Rejestracja: 11.04.2007, 08:36
Lokalizacja: Łódź

Post autor: Bednaar »

Taribo West pisze:
I think Winobranie is also one of my favourite one... maybe just after Astigmatic (i know i am not too original)
Well, my first 2 albums were Winobranie and Asigmatic, too, for a long time... but lately Astigmatic was replaced by Sprzedawcy Glonów (Ptaszyn), Seant (Trzaskowski)... and even Abstract by Przybielski 8)
vertical_invader
Awatar użytkownika
Bart
remaster
Posty: 2075
Rejestracja: 11.04.2007, 05:00
Lokalizacja: East Hampton, CT

Post autor: Bart »

Very interesting, thanks for sharing this with us, Taribo!

What a spread between the old and new, classic and modern, also quite a genre representation, from Kaczmarski to Dezerter... You gave us an unique experience to see that Polish music is appreciated by non-Poles.

Am I surprised with the list? Sure I am! I even don't know half of these titles (newer and less "classic", more "poppy" ones)... I guess I'll take your list as a recommendation and it's time for me to do my homework now... ;) Cheers!
Say you want to know the truth, well you can ask me a question
I'll tell you something that you may want to hear
But I'll lie
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 395
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Post autor: Taribo West »

In the forum we have some expert about polish music, the webzine related to the forum also published a very detailed special on Grechuta

https://www.ondarock.it/songwriter/marekgrechuta.htm

and a milestons for Korowood
https://www.ondarock.it/pietremiliari/m ... orowod.htm

The forum taste are very wide, but maybe little bit focused on 80's music

I was surprised by the result of String connection and Woźniak
Awatar użytkownika
gharvelt
zremasterowany digipack z bonusami
Posty: 5744
Rejestracja: 14.04.2014, 20:52
Lokalizacja: Kraków

Post autor: gharvelt »

I moved this topic to the appropriate section. Every polls, games, competitions and so on should be posted here, in section "Płyty" ("Albums").
ODPOWIEDZ