Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Najciekawsze - najsilniejszych.

Moderatorzy: gharvelt, Bartosz, Dobromir, Moderatorzy

Piotr
maxi-singel kompaktowy
Posty: 746
Rejestracja: 19.07.2019, 10:32

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Piotr »

Looks pretty good!
I hope the final will take place on March 11.
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 396
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Taribo West »

Piotr pisze: 22.02.2023, 13:47 Looks pretty good!
I hope the final will take place on March 11.
It won't be easy, at them moment we are still 10 (4 from Poland). Anyway we have not so much hurry, so i can also move the due date if we don't reach the quorum
Crazy
zremasterowany digipack z bonusami
Posty: 5038
Rejestracja: 19.08.2019, 16:15

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Crazy »

I will definitely send you my vote but I would apreciate NOT being in a hurry.
jeżeli nam zabraknie sił
zostaną jeszcze morze i wiatr
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 396
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Taribo West »

Crazy pisze: 27.02.2023, 21:34 I will definitely send you my vote but I would apreciate NOT being in a hurry.
don't worry :) I postponed the due date at the end of March. It is not my intention to stress you :P

In the meantime i received another list
The list received untill now (for the italian user and use the RYM username):

No.1: Muk (Italy) - 20 titles
No.2: JamesLepo (Italy) - 20 titles
No.3: Taribo West (Italy) - 50 titles
No.4: aurelijus (Italy) - 20 titles
No.5: Okechukwu (Poland) - 20 titles
No.6: AfterTheRain (Italy) - 20 titles
No.7: esforts (Poland) - 20 titles
No.8: Trippaman (Italy) - 50 titles
No.9: MarekJ (Poland) - 20 titles
No.9: Piotr (Poland) - 50 titles
No.10: Mami_Tomoe(*) (Italy) - 30 titles
No.11: alternativepop (Poland) - 50 titles

(*) not on RYM
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 396
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Taribo West »

Crazy pisze: 27.02.2023, 21:34 I will definitely send you my vote but I would apreciate NOT being in a hurry.
don't worry :) I postponed the due date at the end of March. It is not my intention to stress you :P
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 396
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Taribo West »

The list received untill now (for the italian user and use the RYM username):

No.1: Muk (Italy) - 20 titles
No.2: JamesLepo (Italy) - 20 titles
No.3: Taribo West (Italy) - 50 titles
No.4: aurelijus (Italy) - 20 titles
No.5: Okechukwu (Poland) - 20 titles
No.6: AfterTheRain (Italy) - 20 titles
No.7: esforts (Poland) - 20 titles
No.8: Trippaman (Italy) - 50 titles
No.9: MarekJ (Poland) - 20 titles
No.9: Piotr (Poland) - 50 titles
No.10: Mami_Tomoe(*) (Italy) - 30 titles
No.11: alternativepop (Poland) - 50 titles
No.12: Atahualpa (Poland) - 50 titles

(*) not on RYM
Crazy
zremasterowany digipack z bonusami
Posty: 5038
Rejestracja: 19.08.2019, 16:15

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Crazy »

You've got a few live albums on the list but I just noticed that there is one very important missing:

TSA - Live

- the debut album of this band and, at least for me, the best one. And it's got the most famous version of the classic rock ballad 51.
jeżeli nam zabraknie sił
zostaną jeszcze morze i wiatr
Crazy
zremasterowany digipack z bonusami
Posty: 5038
Rejestracja: 19.08.2019, 16:15

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Crazy »

... and looks like there is one too many -
Republika - 82-85 (1985, New Wave, Post-Punk)
I would love to vote for it as it is my favourite Republika album but I don't think it was released in the 1980s. I actually seem to remember when it was released, when I bought the cassette, which I still have and listen to. It was already in the 90s.
jeżeli nam zabraknie sił
zostaną jeszcze morze i wiatr
Piotr
maxi-singel kompaktowy
Posty: 746
Rejestracja: 19.07.2019, 10:32

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Piotr »

Ups... nie wiedziałem i zagłosowałem, no i oczywiście wysoko, bo jakże by inaczej. :)
Ale w sumie ten materiał bardziej pasuje do 80s, więc może już to zostawić?
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 396
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Taribo West »

I don't your rules for archive material, for me it is eligible because it is all material from 80, so it fit better in 80 poll than 90

The final day should be on Sunday, but we are still far from the quorum so my intention is to extend the due date
Piotr
maxi-singel kompaktowy
Posty: 746
Rejestracja: 19.07.2019, 10:32

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Piotr »

Let's see how many people will vote till sunday. Many of them votes at the very end, so I hope quorum will be reached. :)
Crazy
zremasterowany digipack z bonusami
Posty: 5038
Rejestracja: 19.08.2019, 16:15

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Crazy »

I'm having several difficulties now resulting in lack of time. Right now I'm leaving until Sunday and there's no way I can make the list while I'm away. It would be possible on Sunday evening, however not easy. So - if you decide to hold the due date, I will do my best and try to send it to you before midnight. Otherwise, I'd rather do it at a more convenient time.
Taribo West pisze: 23.03.2023, 10:12 I don't your rules for archive material, for me it is eligible because it is all material from 80, so it fit better in 80 poll than 90
That's logical to me but on the other hand if the material was not released in the 80s, can we treat it as an 80s album?
Personally I wouldn't have a problem with that but it's never done this way here. Date of release decides. Then again, this is YOUR poll so YOU decide :-)
TSA - Lice (1983, Hard Rock, Heavy Metal)
Hey, I think naming your album "Lice" would be daring (esp with some of them on the cover art ;-)) but it still lokks like a typo ;-)
jeżeli nam zabraknie sił
zostaną jeszcze morze i wiatr
Crazy
zremasterowany digipack z bonusami
Posty: 5038
Rejestracja: 19.08.2019, 16:15

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Crazy »

One thing before I go -

Fotoness - When I Die (1988)

Zespół Tilt to był dobry zespół, tylko z wydawnictwami im nie szło. Pierwsza płyta w niczym nie przypomina tego, co panowie robili na początku kariery, potem ten Czad kommando (ale to już 1990), trochę jakby nie w czas i w ogóle niewiele po nich zostało. Natomiast efemeryczna formacja Fotoness, którą Lipiński założył po drodze, nagrała rzecz ciekawą, owszem bardzo zakopaną w swojej epoce, brzmiącą wręcz archaicznie, ale fajne piosenki tam są. Nie mówię, że to jakaś świetna płyta, ale na pewno warto poznać.
jeżeli nam zabraknie sił
zostaną jeszcze morze i wiatr
Awatar użytkownika
Taribo West
singel analogowy
Posty: 396
Rejestracja: 06.04.2021, 11:03
Kontakt:

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: Taribo West »

Crazy pisze: 24.03.2023, 05:03 I'm having several difficulties now resulting in lack of time. Right now I'm leaving until Sunday and there's no way I can make the list while I'm away. It would be possible on Sunday evening, however not easy. So - if you decide to hold the due date, I will do my best and try to send it to you before midnight. Otherwise, I'd rather do it at a more convenient time.
Ok i think there is no problem to postpone to one week. New due date 01/04, but pls if possible try to not send all the lists in the last day, so i have the feeling if we can reach the quorum or not
Crazy pisze: 24.03.2023, 05:03 That's logical to me but on the other hand if the material was not released in the 80s, can we treat it as an 80s album?
Personally I wouldn't have a problem with that but it's never done this way here. Date of release decides. Then again, this is YOUR poll so YOU decide :-)
Great I like to have power :P
Republika - 82-85 is valid for me. So you can vote it

Crazy pisze: 24.03.2023, 05:03
TSA - Lice (1983, Hard Rock, Heavy Metal)
Hey, I think naming your album "Lice" would be daring (esp with some of them on the cover art ;-)) but it still lokks like a typo ;-)
yes it was a typo
Awatar użytkownika
B.J.
box z pełną dyskografią i gadżetami
Posty: 14151
Rejestracja: 11.04.2007, 21:33

Re: Z ziemi włoskiej do Polski - najlepszy polski album dekady 1980-89

Post autor: B.J. »

Crazy pisze: 22.03.2023, 15:19 ... and looks like there is one too many -
Republika - 82-85 (1985, New Wave, Post-Punk)
I would love to vote for it as it is my favourite Republika album but I don't think it was released in the 1980s. I actually seem to remember when it was released, when I bought the cassette, which I still have and listen to. It was already in the 90s.
Piotr pisze: 22.03.2023, 20:00 Ups... nie wiedziałem i zagłosowałem, no i oczywiście wysoko, bo jakże by inaczej. :)
Ale w sumie ten materiał bardziej pasuje do 80s, więc może już to zostawić?
Taribo West pisze: 23.03.2023, 10:12 I don't your rules for archive material, for me it is eligible because it is all material from 80, so it fit better in 80 poll than 90
For me this case is simple. This compilation of (mainly or only) singles from 80s was released in 90s. It is not an album as others. It is not fair for others to vote for this. It should be withdrawn from the competition.

This material is of course superior and this music made great impact in 80s, but the compilation is from 1993. This is fact. These songs were not intended to be an album. They were in fact single and radio hits in 80s. It not fair for other artists to compete with their regular albums.
ODPOWIEDZ